A New Path for an Old Book

By:
Carol J. Binkowski

I love real books. However, our venerable 270-year-old Library, with its atmosphere of a bygone era, is not where I expected to find inspiration for a social media project—even one related to books.

First, a bit of background. Years ago, I wrote a brief, informal history/walking tour of musical sites in New York. It was an enjoyable experience. But, commemorative plaques, buildings, street signs, and such can change or vanish quickly, just as new ones spring up—and before long, the book was out of date. Doing a second edition occasionally crossed my mind, but that’s as far as it went. I had already turned to other projects.

When I met Tienya Smith, the subject came up by pure chance. She enthusiastically suggested updating the book—not in print form but in a blog and photos via Instagram—an effective way to keep information current. Her point was a good one.

We talked again at a Library event, and she asked if I’d considered the idea. I agreed that it was a fine and intriguing thought, but social media wasn’t my strong suit. She then graciously offered to get me started.

Tienya guided me through setting up an account and identifying myself as a music writer. She suggested browsing to see what was out there and analyzing all facets of what I had discovered. After guiding me through a test post and ways to caption a photo, she urged me to continue exploring and to contact her with any questions. Soon, I was immersed in the wide world of cyberspace. It brought surprising revelations and, also, raised substantial questions.

I browsed through many music, music writer, city landmark, and related sites. The variety was far more expansive than I’d imagined. There was a piano teacher with an energetic mix of pictures, reels, narratives and links that opened my eyes to how well-presented posts can be helpful and meaningful. A classical radio station featured unique innovations in performance. A pair of photographers focused on smaller, often forgotten city sites. (Was there any musical connection in their pasts? Yes! I discovered two already.) My explorations continued—music magazines, concert halls, museums, history buffs, performers.

When I looked back at my original book, so much had changed—not just some sites but, also, the world. From apps to podcasts and more, people are less apt to be strolling with a physical guidebook in hand. I’d changed, too. Instead of just updating my former book, I now wanted to take a broader look at the topic of musical sites and maybe expand this to include other locations. I wanted to enjoy the exploration, informally share this with others and, perhaps, discover a new print book idea along the way.

As intriguing as all of this was, it also raised questions—from proper length of the commentary to organization of the posts. Rights and permissions for use of certain materials and photos especially needed to be considered—even if the photos were now informally taken with my cellphone. And in the vast world of the internet, guidelines for this seemed hazy at best.

A post from Carol Binkowski's Instagram, about the vintage periodical THE MUSICAL COURIER

If I wanted to photograph a plaque on a private brownstone, for example, that stated “such-and-such a composer lived here a hundred years ago,” permission could be a must. Homeowners needed their privacy, and designers or a sponsoring organization could hold rights to the plaque itself. Better to avoid the whole thing altogether, I thought. But then how to refer to the information sans photo in an online setting? And what about a concert hall? Or a statue of, say, Beethoven in the park? Getting professional or archival photos for a print book with their associated permissions was one thing; and, even then, caution was always preferable. Figuring out the issues of using one’s own photos for an informal internet site felt like free-falling.

I contacted the legal department at the Authors Guild and outlined my dilemma. They sent me thorough information that I read through several times and discussed this with a fellow author with a legal background. More questions arose. Aside from certain obvious things to be avoided, much was open to interpretation. If posting certain “gray-area” materials would be for scholarship/intellectual commentary or similar purposes, a case could be made for fair use.  Clearly defining fair use was another matter. Also, was there any personal gain involved? It certainly wasn’t for any monetary rewards, but were there other gains not so obvious?

Additional questions came up, too. Since this whole journey began with thinking about a printed book, what role would books play for me with this new and different way of handling the subject? Would all of my information come from online sources?

I pondered these questions as I wrote this blog, squirreled away at a remote study desk in Stack #2 at the Library, surrounded by the comforting presence of lots of real books. As fascinating as it has been to explore new worlds online, I realized it was still equally exciting to make discoveries by plunging back into the old printed worlds, as well. Two aging tomes I’d just picked up contained some pages about landmark sites that immediately sparked new ideas for further research. There is a vastness within these books, too, that can complement the vastness of the internet.

I’m still exploring answers to my questions and am enjoying my Instagram blog, still very much in its infancy. Also, I’m so grateful for all of the help and inspiration from Tienya, who also suggested writing this blog to share my journey should others find it interesting.

Finally, I’m grateful to be a member of a Library that maintains a respect for the value of real books, just as it has also ventured into new territories by offering substantial online resources and expanding its building for current and future needs. The Library is a wonderful role model, and one I hope to follow.

Carol J. Binkowski's books include Opening Carnegie Hall: The Creation and First Performances of America's Premier Concert Stage. Find her on Instagram @musicwriter114.